Today was an excellent example, I haven’t flown in a couple of
weeks and really wanted to but wasn’t sure weather wise. The cloud base was
low-ish but the winds were ok. The snow that we’d had looked to be over but
there was still a lot of moisture in the air, with vague threats of freezing
drizzle.
Bob and I agreed to look at the weather first thing in the morning
and judge it from there. I woke up, looked out the window and figured that we
probably wouldn’t be flying. RTH helpfully pulled up a GFA chart and showed me
the nice icing and turbulence reports on it. I was mildly surprised to get a
text from Bob saying that he was good to go. I didn’t want to second guess him
but I did point out the icing stuff.
Now Bob has waaaay more experience than me in judging weather conditions
and I trust him implicitly not to put me in danger but there comes a time where
if you’re uncertain you should speak up. I often employ the mindset of “what
would you say at an accident investigation?*” How would you justify your decision?
What sounds better from a person who is meant to be training to be
Pilot-In-Command, “my instructor told me we could fly, so I did” or “I looked
at all the weather data available to me, I was still unsure if it was safe to
fly, so I asked his opinion and he explained to me why it was safe for us to go
and what special precautions we’d need to take to remain safe”?
In this case we kept a careful eye on the cloud base, waited until
a flight that was due back arrived and got a PIREP from the instructor. We also
discussed the fact that I’d have to fly a lower than usual circuit in order to
remain VFR. There was also a C-152 right in front of us so we could keep an eye
on what it was doing.
As it turned out I only managed to get a couple of circuits in
before the cloud descended to the point where we needed to come back in. The visibility
was not good. Bob said to me “we can call it a day if you like.” I was about to
say that we`d keep it up for another circuit, but then I noticed that a) the
C-152 in front of us had called it quits and b) I could no longer distinguish between
the lake and the sky off to my left. It was time to land.
I`m still glad we took it up for a spin though. It was a good
lesson in weather interpretation, deciding your personal limits, pushing your
comfort zones and generally making good decisions. While I might not choose to
fly in the conditions we had today. It`s good to know that I can keep my head
and land in them.
* it may sound melodramatic but it is generally good life advice. If you are unsure if you are making the right call, explain your decision to someone else. If it sounds wrong out loud, you are about to do something stupid!
* it may sound melodramatic but it is generally good life advice. If you are unsure if you are making the right call, explain your decision to someone else. If it sounds wrong out loud, you are about to do something stupid!
Very good advice LFE. Two comments. 1) Your assessment of Bobs judgement is spot on. His seemingly offhand suggestion about landing was a test of your command ability and I think you passed it. 2) Part of your training is to experience flight in different weather conditions. As you say, you have to have some sort of baseline of weather where you say to yourself, I think I will remain on terra firma today. The only way to do this is to get up there and see for yourself.
ReplyDeleteI would not call this post pushing your limits. Finding what your limits are is more apt :-)
Flyinkiwi, I love getting your comments, you spot so much that I don't sometimes and make me feel really good about myself! Thank you sir!
ReplyDeleteI hadn't even thought that iwas being "tested" as it were but I have a felling you may well be right. I've said it before and I'll say it again Bob can be a devious b@st@rd sometimes. And I thought I was the one who was good at manipulating people! Please understand I mean no disrepct by this , more of an grudging admiration!
it just goes to show then I spend pointless hours agonizing over small ridiculous details but put me on the spot and I make the right choice!
Yeah I don't think I'd be flying in that low cloud base myself but I'm glad I got the experience of seeing what it looked like and how the view out of one window can be fine but the other side is just grey,grey ,grey!
Am workign my way through your blog, great stuff. I swear I could have written some of the exact same thoughts myself